you know the drill
1995: Toy Story (Runner-Up: Jumanji)
1996: Space Jam (Runner-Up: Trainspotting)
1997: Men in Black (Runner-Up: Bean)
1998: The Truman Show (Runner-Up: The Big Lebowski)
1999: Pokémon: The First Movie (Runner-Up: Fight Club)
2000: Final Destination (Runner-Up: X-Men)
2001: Spirited Away (Runner-Up: Monsters, Inc.)
2002: Minority Report (Runner-Up: Spider-Man)
2003: Bruce Almighty (Runner-Up: Johnny English)
2004: Harold & Kumar Go to White Castle (Runner-Up: Napoleon Dynamite)
2005: The Pacifier (Runner-Up: Madagascar)
2006: Tenacious D in The Pick of Destiny (Runner-Up: Final Destination III)
2007: Hot Fuzz (Runner-Up: Mr. Bean's Holiday)
2008: The Dark Knight (Runner-Up: Sex Drive)
2009: The Hangover (Runner-Up: Zombieland)
2010: The Book of Eli (Runner-Up: Kick-Ass)
2011: The Hangover: Part II (Runner-Up: Scre4m)